top of page

An update from Paul Thorogood, KAUS Chairman

zanattalynn
4 days ago
3 min read

MONKS FARM OUTLINE APPLICATION APPROVED – A DEEPLY DISAPPOINTING DECISION FOR KELVEDON, FEERING AND COGGESHALL

Braintree District Council’s Planning Committee has voted to approve 600 homes at Monks Farm, Kelvedon (21/03579/OUT), despite serious and unresolved concerns about highways, infrastructure and significant harm to our countryside.

Perhaps most astonishingly, councillors approved the application without knowing how Essex Highways intends to resolve the already congested junction of Station Road, Kelvedon High Street, Feering Hill and Swan Street.

Essex Highways has withdrawn its long-standing objection in return for proposed mitigation, including a £918,000 contribution towards highway improvements. Yet there is no clearly defined scheme, no demonstrated solution and no guarantee that the money will be sufficient.

Members have effectively approved hundreds of additional homes on the promise that somebody will work out how to deal with the traffic later. That is not a credible approach to planning.

Equally troubling is the decision to approve the development despite evidence from independent landscape consultants identifying significant harm to the character and appearance of the surrounding countryside.

This development will permanently change the landscape around Kelvedon. Such harm cannot simply be dismissed or mitigated by planting a few trees.

Monks Farm is also effectively the first phase of the much larger Kings Dene proposals, potentially involving thousands more homes, which have yet to undergo independent examination through the Local Plan process.

Approving these 600 homes separately risks prejudicing the proper assessment of the wider scheme and its cumulative impact on roads, sewage, water supplies, schools and healthcare.

There was one important amendment. The committee agreed to remove the April 2030 date from a condition relating to sewage infrastructure, following concerns expressed by Cllr James Abbott about wastewater capacity. However, that does not resolve the wider infrastructure problems.

The Conservative majority on the committee voted in favour of the application, alongside two Labour councillors and a Halstead resident member. Green councillor James Abbott was the only member to vote against.

I addressed the committee in my capacity as the local county councillor, alongside Christa Dobson, speaking for Kelvedon Against Urban Sprawl (KAUS), local residents Sam Selby and Lynn Zanatta, and representatives of Coggeshall and Kelvedon Parish Councils and Heritage Society.

All raised important concerns about the consequences of this development. Sadly, our arguments were not enough to persuade the majority of committee members.

I want to pay particular tribute to the extraordinary KAUS volunteers, our independent highways, landscape and planning consultants, our legal advisers and the many residents who have devoted countless unpaid hours to challenging this application.

Their commitment, determination and professionalism have been remarkable.

What concerns me most is the precedent this decision sets. If 600 homes can be approved without a clearly identified solution to one of the area’s most congested junctions, what confidence can residents have that the infrastructure needed for the thousands more homes proposed through Kings Dene will ever be delivered?

I have always accepted that new homes are needed. But development must be properly planned, supported by adequate infrastructure and assessed for its cumulative impact on existing communities.

Tonight’s decision is a major setback, but it is not the end of the story.

We will carefully examine the decision, consult our professional advisers and consider what options remain available.

Kelvedon, Feering and Coggeshall deserve better than development approved before the necessary infrastructure solutions have even been identified.

We will continue to stand up for our communities.

A big thank you to everyone who attended tonight’s meeting - now you know what I have to deal with on a weekly basis!

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page