top of page

Letter from Kelvedon resident, Graham Holland to Braintree District Council re proposed 600 home 'Monks Farm' development (21/03579/OUT)

zanattalynn
Oct 27
3 min read


Dear Councillor Spray,


Many thanks for your kind reply acknowledging my letter of objection to the proposed 600 homes at Monks Farm.

I have a further question which I would be grateful if you could help me understand, particularly in relation to the position of Essex Highways.

The Monks Farm planning application (Ref: 21/03579/OUT) has been progressing through the planning process since December 2021. My understanding is that, during this period, Essex Highways raised objections to the application on the grounds of traffic congestion and the significant impact that the development would have on the local highway network.

I understand, however, that Essex Highways has recently withdrawn its objection following negotiations with the developer, with a mitigation package reportedly valued at approximately £2.8 million.

This raises some very serious questions for me.

Since the original application was submitted in 2021, Kelvedon and Feering have not seen any significant highway or infrastructure improvements capable of addressing the existing congestion and pressure on the local road network. Indeed, during this same period, approximately 1233 additional homes have either been constructed or are currently under construction in and around the surrounding area.

Consequently, the existing highway network is already under considerable pressure, with congestion regularly experienced in Kelvedon, Feering, Coggeshall and the surrounding villages.

I am particularly concerned about the cumulative impact of adding a further 600 homes at Monks Farm. Depending on household size and car ownership, this could potentially introduce a further 1,200–1,800 residents and a substantial number of additional vehicles onto a local road network that is already struggling to cope with existing demand.

The B1024 in particular is a relatively constrained local route, and additional traffic from Monks Farm would inevitably have implications not only for Kelvedon and Feering but also for Coggeshall and other surrounding villages.

There is also an important heritage consideration. Coggeshall is a historic village with numerous listed buildings and buildings of significant architectural and historical importance, including Paycockes, one of Essex's most important historic buildings. Increased traffic, congestion, vibration and vehicle movements through these historic areas could have long-term consequences for the character and condition of this heritage environment.

Against this background, I find it difficult to understand how a contribution of £2.8 million can be considered sufficient mitigation for the scale of highway impact that a development of this size could create.

More importantly, I would like to understand what has changed between Essex Highways' original position and its current position. If the underlying highway conditions have not materially improved, and if the surrounding area has continued to experience significant housing growth and increased traffic, what evidence or assessment has enabled Essex Highways to conclude that its previous objection can now be withdrawn?

I would therefore be grateful if you could ask for clarification on the following points:

What specific highway concerns did Essex Highways originally raise in relation to application 21/03579/OUT?

What precisely does the £2.8 million mitigation package comprise, and what highway improvements will it actually deliver?

How was the £2.8 million figure calculated, and what assessment demonstrates that this level of funding is proportionate to the cumulative highway impact of the development?

Has Essex Highways undertaken an updated assessment of the cumulative impact of the approximately 733 homes already built or under construction in the area, together with the additional 600 homes proposed at Monks Farm?

Has the potential impact on Coggeshall and other surrounding villages, including their historic buildings and heritage assets, been fully assessed?

Was the decision to withdraw the objection subject to any independent review or scrutiny, and if so, by whom?

What specific evidence demonstrates that the proposed mitigation will prevent the development from creating unacceptable congestion or worsening existing highway problems?

I fully appreciate that development contributions are intended to mitigate the impact of new development. However, I am concerned that the withdrawal of a formal highway objection following agreement of a financial package could give the impression that a serious and longstanding highway objection has effectively been resolved through a financial contribution, rather than through a demonstrable solution to the underlying transport problems.

I therefore believe this matter deserves further scrutiny, particularly given the scale of the proposed development and the cumulative housing growth that has taken place in the area since the original application was submitted.

I would be very grateful if you could raise these concerns with the relevant officers and, in particular, seek clarification regarding the professional and technical basis upon which Essex Highways has changed its position.

My concern is not simply about the £2.8 million figure itself; it is about whether the proposed mitigation can genuinely address the long-term highway consequences of adding another 600 homes to an already heavily pressured road network.

Thank you again for taking the time to consider my concerns. I look forward to hearing your views and, if possible, receiving clarification on the points above.

Kind regards

Graham Holland

Ewell Hall

Ewell Hall Chase

Kelvedon

Essex

CO5 9BQ

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
An update from Paul Thorogood, KAUS Chairman

MONKS FARM OUTLINE APPLICATION APPROVED – A DEEPLY DISAPPOINTING DECISION FOR KELVEDON, FEERING AND COGGESHALL Braintree District Council’s Planning Committee has voted to approve 600 homes at Monks F

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page